Frank Miller’s 300


I finished reading Frank Miller’s 300 on Thursday evening. After Alan Moore’s very hefty 400 page-plus Watchmen, 300 was an absolute breeze to read – it could be finished in 1 or 2 sittings very easily.

I suppose any graphic novel is a bit of a come-down after the depth of Watchmen. While 300 is exceptionally beautiful to look at – essentially each panel could be wall-mounted as art – the story is a stripped down and stylised take on the Battle of Thermopylae, in which 300 Spartans (King Leonidas and his personal bodyguard of 300 men) defended Greece against a massive invading force of Persians.

At times the novel seems to be a simplified celebration of machismo. Chapter titles include Courage, Honour, Victory. At other times, Miller seems to let a critique of these qualities seep through – as arrogant as Persian king Xerxes is, the main atrocities and abuses seem to be committed by the Spartans, who spend a great deal of time celebrating their role as ‘defenders of democracy and reason’. Sound vaguely familiar?


It’s also refreshing to discover that for all of 300’s stylisation, as the novel progresses, the reader does begin to empathise with Leonidas (the single, strongly realised character), and share in his concern about the fate of his ‘boys’. You do start to care about these characters, and admire their unshaken bravery.

So 300 is definitely worth a read, although I do have the feeling that Zack Snyder’s film, out in the first quarter of 2007, will actually flesh out and hopefully add some additional layers to the storyline, while remaining utterly faithful visually. The trailers certainly suggest this… as well as the fact that Gerard Butler was born to play Leonidas.


Speaking of 300 – The Movie, some beautiful wallpapers for film are now online here.

Comments

Anonymous said…
It is interesting to see how the Iraq war and the Bush administration policies are seeping into pop culture and being reflected back to us, be it a graphic novel of the Battle of Thermopylae or the Simpsons Treehouse of Horror. I wonder if Miller will go through with his Batman vs. al-Qaeda?
Pfangirl said…
Hmm, it's weird.

I don't think it's coincidence we're seeing the 300 film now in terms of its 'Brave, Democratic West vs Evil Middle East' storyline, although it was written in the late 1990s.

Then again, Kingdom of Heaven, which came out post-911 treated Muslim vs Christian conflict quite sensitively, perhaps even too sensitively / politically correctly.

I'd love to see Miller's al-Quaeda story, although I struggle to see how it can top Death in the Family in the 1980s, which had the Joker representing Iran at the UN.
Anonymous said…
Actually this is a greek legend about how sparta along with the help of athens( which is not in the graphic novel) defeated the invading persian army. there have been many versions of this story and many books written about. All frank miller did was put his own little flar to the story. and a movie called the 300 spartans was made in the 40s or somewhere around there because it is in black and white. the release of the movie has nothing to do with america versus the middle east or anything like that. and the word america is not even spoken in the movie. in fact when the legend happened america hadnt been found by white people yet. the movie is about greeks fighting persians, not iraqis or afghanis, persians. dont make it into something that it isnt

Popular posts from this blog

Is the rebooted Lara Croft gay? Evidence for and against...

Weekend report-back: beach, board games and books

Movies today, SA!